Mobile devices.
Mobile devices are crap.
I love gadgets, I really do but I’m in the process of deciding upon a new phone for when I find employment to fit around college, and it’s made me realize, current devices are crap.
Ok, maybe crap is a little unfair, but there is nothing yet good enough to tempt me away from my HTC Excalibur, which while a little behind on the times is absolutely rock solid, which for a windows mobile device you’d think is rare. I think I’ve had to forcefully restart it once in the year and a half of ownership.
Which devices have I considered?
- Nokia E71
- SE Xperia X1
- T-Mobile G1
Let’s tackle the G1 first, as this was the device I was looking forward to (Well maybe not THIS device, but Android devices) and the biggest disappointment along the way. My problem is NOT with Android, which while it’s a little immature is a fantastic platform, my issue is with the device itself, there’s really nothing special about it and a lot of annoyances:
- HTC (the OEM for the G1) are up to their usual tricks with stupid MiniUSB ports, I understand the logic behind this, that is everything can be done via one port but it’s simply an annoyance, there is no standard 3.5mm headphone jack, meaning to use my shiny Sennheisers I have to purchase an adaptor, which either adds more mass or more cabling (as with my Excalibur).
- I’m not a shallow guy; in fact I prefer function over form, but it is hideous, amirite?
- That angled chin, again I understand the logic behind it, the microphone being angled towards the mouth but it adds to the hideousness and makes it awkward to keep in the pocket.
- The keyboard, it’s shit, ’nuff said really, the keys are way way way too flat, there’s next to no travel, they might as well have saved some mass and cost and slapped a nasty virtual keyboard on there
I’m not sure whether it’s that I got my hopes up too high for HTC delivering on this one or whether it’s just a crap device, either way it lets the software down, in a big, big way. I expected HTC to break away from the norm slightly and deliver something special, and while the half decent processor, nice chunk (192mb) of ram is nice, it just seems like R&D at HTC had a very boring year.
Now the Xperia X1. Such a fantastic looking device with some interesting concepts, and best of all, it doesn’t make me look like some blackberry carrying businesspersonthing. The ‘panels’ concept is interesting, even if it is a bit of a gimmick. The idea behind it is that you can have multiple ‘desktops’ (homescreens) that you can quickly switch, depending on the type of use currently in hand, be it business/personal/whatever, this is a nice concept in theory but why do I need to waste memory and cpu cycles when it would take me exactly 10 seconds to switch via the settings menu? The device specs are fantastic, accelerated gpu, 384mb ram, etc. For me, this device is almost perfect, my problems with it are: The stupid ‘optical joystick’ again, an unneeded gimmick, what is it with you and optical gimmicks HTC? (HTC is the OEM for the X1 also) I mean, didn’t you learn from the ‘JOGGR’ on the Excalibur that was almost universally disabled because it was about as useful as a feather duster in the sahara when it worked and had a mind of its own doing all kinds of funky shit when it didn’t (most of the time, then)? The second and most significant is SE’s unwillingness to comment whether they will be offering a Windows Mobile 7 firmware upgrade when it becomes available.
Windows Mobile gets a LOT of stick, most of it undeserved which I think stems from the “Windows” stigma and a slew of shitty devices with poor driver support (not WM’s fault) and shitty implementations(again, not the fault of WM). Windows mobile is fairly generic, and it’s up to vendors to provide decent drivers and implement features properly, if they don’t do this, it’s a piece of shit, simple as that. I absolutely LOVE my HTC Excalibur and it has been nothing but stable with the stock HTC Windows Mobile 6 upgrade (though I do frequently try cooked roms) which is why I am so reluctant to break away from it.
With that said, Windows Mobile, at least in it’s current form is starting to get a little dated and is in desperate need of an overhaul, which is basically what Windows Mobile 7 promises, scheduled for release in the second half of 2009. So essentially by not commenting Sony Ericsson are saying that you could be buying into a (very expensive, if not subsidized by a network contract) device that is obsolete before having even been in the market a year.
Now, onto the Nokia E71, it looks to be a good device, but the stupid shiny finger print attracting surfaces? Not so much. It looks a little too ‘blackberry’ for my liking (I know, I know, I own an Excalibur) and having owned an early N95 I am yet to get over the pain, the early N95 firmwares were dog slow, inefficient and ran out of memory routinely, buggy and the battery was nothing short of useless. So I suppose I’m dismissing it based on bad experiences with Nokia and S60.
I think I’ll hold on for a while and see what the next Android devices deliver, and/or how Windows Mobile 7 performs if SE decide to offer an upgrade.
